12458 — Sullivan County, New York Market Snapshot
Housing market data for zip code 12458 in Sullivan County, New York. Updated monthly with median prices, days on market, and more.
Limited Sales Data
Only 4 homes sold in this ZIP code during the selected period. Statistics may not be representative. See the Sullivan County county page for broader data.
Market Sales Data
4 sales in 2026 (year to date)
Median Sale Price
$541,500
Days to Sell
82
Homes Sold
4
Inventory
8
Conforming Loan Available
Most homebuyers in 12458 can comfortably use conventional financing. The median home price of $541,500 is well below the 2026 conforming loan limit of $832,750, meaning buyers can put as little as 3-5% down without hitting jumbo loan territory.
Market Insights
Market Temperature
With homes sitting for 82 days on average, 12458 favors buyers. There may be opportunities to negotiate below asking price or request seller concessions for closing costs or rate buydowns.
Conforming Loan Feasibility
Most homebuyers in 12458 can comfortably use conventional financing. The median home price of $541,500 is well below the 2026 conforming loan limit of $832,750, meaning buyers can put as little as 3-5% down without hitting jumbo loan territory.
Loan limits in 12458 are set at the county level.
2026 Loan Limits — Sullivan County
| Property Units | Conforming Limit | FHA Limit |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Unit | $832,750 | $541,287 |
| 2 Units | $1,066,250 | $693,050 |
| 3 Units | $1,288,800 | $837,700 |
| 4 Units | $1,601,750 | $1,041,125 |
Affordability Snapshot — Zip 12458
To purchase the median home at $541,500 with 5% down at today's rate of 6.75%, the estimated monthly payment is approximately $4,299.
Monthly Payment
$4,299
Income Required
$184,234
Principal & Interest
$3,337/mo
Down Payment (5%)
$27,075
Based on 30-year fixed at 6.75%, 1.8% property tax, $1,800/yr insurance, 28% DTI guideline.
Mortgage Calculator
Estimate your monthly payment for a home in 12458.
Estimated Monthly Payment
$3,501
Connect with a LoanGraphs Loan Officer
Get expert guidance for zip code 12458. Tell us what you're looking for.